Opinion: What is the fate of the Exiled Dictator in Harare [Mengistu Haile Mariam]?

Well, as the day progress and the coup d’état in Harare. That has toppled President Robert Mugabe in the last 48 hours, as the Zimbabwe African National Union – Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) power struggle has led to the demise of the 37 years of Mugabe. Why it is important is that the former Ethiopian dictator who left for exile was there on the accord of Mugabe. His powers and his control is out. Therefore, it now matters to the current leadership in Addis Ababa and the new in Harare. What will happen with this old-man, whose saving grace was the opening arms of Mugabe. But now that has no currency in any trade.

Almost five years since a civil war overthrew the Marxist military dictatorship of Lieut. Col. Mengistu Haile Mariam, the challenge for Ethiopia has been not only to create a new identity, but also to deal with its heritage” (…) “Colonel Mengistu’s rule tried to obliterate this heritage and create a Marxist state. In the process, tens of thousands of people were killed, including the Emperor, as many were tortured and more than a million peasants were relocated. In a war against guerrilla fighters, Colonel Mengistu’s military bombed entire regions, flattening towns and propagating a reign of terror” (Lorch, 1995)

The Dergue had been executing suspected EPRP members since 1976, but after Mengistu seized full control in 1977, the “Red Terror” was officially unleashed. During this two-year campaign, which has been divided into “three waves,” tens of thousands of Ethiopians were arrested, tortured, and summarily executed. To assist in exterminating the Dergue’s political opponents and “enemies of the revolution,” Mengistu employed the secret police and issued arms to local government, or kebele, officials (Mayfield 1995)” (USBCIS, 1999).

So a man who fled Ethiopia in 1991 and got to exile, are no an open question, as he was the guest of Mugabe. Will the new administration want his presence or do they want him gone? What is their thoughts after toppling on dictator, do they want to have the second one lingering, even if he isn’t their own?

An airport official said Colonel Mengistu was wearing green fatigues and looked “close to tears.” The Zimbabwean President, Robert Mugabe, who invited Colonel Mengistu here as a way to resolve Ethiopia’s civil war, insisted that the arrival be kept as quiet as possible. Mr. Mugabe was at the airport just an hour earlier, but he left for London on a private visit, avoiding any public meeting with the Ethiopian. Mugabe Returns a Favor. The Zimbabwe Government has issued no statement on Colonel Mengistu, and given no confirmation or denial of his presence in the country. But Government officials have said that Colonel Mengistu is expected to settle here” (New York Times, 1991).

That means that the exiled dictator and the man behind the Red Terror of Ethiopia has been living in Harare since 1991, that means 26 years he has had in peaceful existence there. While this has happen in Ethiopian Supreme Court in January 2007, the exiled President was sentenced to death in his absence. That meaning, if he has to return to Ethiopia. It will he his direct demise and himself paying the price for his leadership in Ethiopia between 1976 and 1991. Clearly, the EPRDF the one party overthrowing the DERG want to retaliate, especially considering that he fled and has been sentenced since leaving.

So we can wonder what will be his fate, will the TPLF or the EPRDF ask for his Extradition from Zimbabwe? Or will they just let him be or will the new leadership ask him to leave and where should he go? Since he would in midst turmoil in Ethiopia and hard for someone sentenced to death in their homeland to become refugee on humanitarian grounds. Even if he wants to try to become political refugee, most likely very few countries wants his residence, except for Equatorial Guinea who recently accepted Yayha Jammeh from Gambia. Peace.


New York Times – ‘EX-ETHIOPIA CHIEF REACHES ZIMBABWE’ (23.05.1991) link: http://www.nytimes.com/1991/05/23/world/ex-ethiopia-chief-reaches-zimbabwe.html

Lorch, Donatella – ‘ Ethiopia Deals With Legacy of Kings and Colonels’ (31.12.1995) link: http://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/31/world/ethiopia-deals-with-legacy-of-kings-and-colonels.html

United States Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services (USBCIS) – ‘Ethiopia: Background Information on the Mengistu Regime during the Red Terror’ (28.12.1999) link: http://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6a6b414.html

5 thoughts on “Opinion: What is the fate of the Exiled Dictator in Harare [Mengistu Haile Mariam]?”

  1. It is interesting for me,as an Ethiopian, that you took interest and wrote about the exiled leader. While I admire your unique talent to get your page listed in the top ten by writing about a news worthy person, but I do not think you have made your research about this specific leader(former) of Ethiopia. For instance, check out this facebook post: “https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1667601316833787&id=1534564533470800&substory_index=0” .Obviously Mengistu is active in Zimbabwean politics. There had been reports also that he had received Zimbabwean citizenship. And Mengistu was not just the guest of Mr. Mugabe for personal reasons. He was hosted by the state because he assisted them during their revolution. Lucky for him though, Grace Mugabe is not going to be president because those with liberation war background are consolidating their power over Zimbabwe as we speak.

  2. Thanks for the link and your opinion as well. There aren’t that easy finding information on a secretive man as Mengistu. I look upon your link. I didn’t know his role as advisor within the Zimbabwe army now. That is why is a opinion piece and not directly all clear information. Since I don’t have it. I writing because, he has a history and the Derg was a violent marxist regime, which led rise of the great leader of Meles Zenawi. But thanks for informing me and enlightening me. We learn new things everyday.

    And I just found old articles on him and nothing newer that seemed truthful. That is why part of me reasearch was small and limited. Because Mengistu seems like a leader who works in the shadows of power. Therefore, little have been written about him.

  3. Unfortunately, you had 10% of what you said.
    Mengistu was a failed Marxist, and a nationalist who made a mistake in Ethiopia.
    Though he was number one to stand by your people. The red terror in Ethiopia is controversial, who were directly Involved, who started that chaos and bloodshed ? You can argue that Mengistu killed people, we cried…but the current dictators killed Ethiopians and Ethiopia.
    Do you know in what condition we are now.? The offspring of fascist collaborators divided our people, they made 100 million people landlocked. No sea access. They said ” we don’t need port”. They killed Ethiopia.
    They are 100 times killers than mengistu.

    I respect The Zimbabweans current demand.
    The person who leads should be the one who is elected by the people.

    Our government wins “100%” in every election.

  4. Leave mengstu alone. Mengstu his’t reside erope. Why u worry about him ?
    We african we cheated so maney times by international so called gonocide the office is in erope looks like we are animal. Pls care about ur home not about us we just try to rule our self according to our calture not on ur calture
    We r fade up of ur new vandaliz
    Gay right
    Children right
    Women right
    We sick tired from ur bulshit pls God almightey we miss ur judgment

    1. I’m European and that is fine. I know my place in the world. I have no issues concerning that. I have all but respect for Africans and their rich culture and history. But asking what will be the fate of a former dictator. Should be without reason and also wondering how his place will be after Mugabe’s fall. You are smart and wise people, who deserve good leadership and respecting civic rights for its citizens. I am just offering my opinions. You don’t have to care about them or even commenting on them. However you did! I know I might often be wrong, but I ask questions and also tries to find the facts. So if you check my track-record. You know I am not like many others. I just wondered what will be his fate and place, as he has a history as a leader. If that is so wrong, please explain that to me!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.